Home
MJD homepage image.

My Books
Defence and
Security Sector

Reality-Based
Self Defence

Self Defence
Fencing
My University
Club Forums

Avenger
Enterprises

My Blog
My Bio
& Other Stuff


The University of Sunderland Fencing Club

The Fencing Club is one of the oldest at the university. We do not know when it was founded, but it had definitely been running for several years (at least) when I joined in 1987. I took over as coach in 1989 and have run the class ever since.

The club is open to students of the University, or ex-students of any University who obtain an Associate Student Union Membership card. The class meets in Wearmouth Sports Centre (Over the swimming pool) 12-4PM on Saturdays and at Crowtree 7-9PM on Tuesdays. On Tuesdays we meet at 6:30 outside Edinburgh building.

All you need to try fencing is trainers and a t-shirt. We can supply all other necessary kit. And it’s cheap. Membership is the standard £5 per year for a sports club plus £1 per session.

Right: Lydia (centre) was the second woman to ever win our Best First-Year Fencer trophy. It was jointly won the next year by two more women; Marianne and Unna. We simply were not able to choose between them.

Marianne will be captaining our womens’ team in BUSA this year. They were extremely successful last time, so we have high hopes for more silverware.

Fencing Photos

Fencing is a competitive sport, though the degree of competition varies. Some people fence for recreation in the club, others are determined competitors. It really is up to the students whether or not they become involved in competition, and how seriously. For those that want it there is BUSA, local novice and senior competitions, nationals and internationals. We have sent people to all levels of competition and even had a fencer invited to the Commonwealth Games some years ago.

We have both male and female BUSA teams and there is room on the team for beginners – competition experience is, to a great extent, the fast-track to becoming an accomplished fencer (that and good coaching; we like to think we can provide that).

We teach modern 'Sport' fencing at the club, though with a healthy respect for the historical origins of what we do – these were once deadly weapons and I tend to view fencing as a martial art as much as a sport. That is, if ever you found yourself in a fight with actual swords, what we teach would serve you well.

Modern "Olympic" fencing uses three weapons: the Foil, Epee and Sabre (Sabre).

Some fencers specialize with one weapon and fence the others only for an occasional diversion - or not at all. Most fence Foil as their main weapon and either Epee or Sabre as a secondary interest, and some try to be all-rounders. Which approach is chosen really depends upon the individual and the available clubs or coaches. As a rule though, if you want to be good, you pick one weapon as your main interest and really work at it, switching focus for a change of pace.

The Foil: A light, point-only weapon descended from the Smallsword or Court Sword. Foil fencing is where almost everyone starts, and they rapidly discover that a foil is only "light" until you try to take an hour-long lesson with one! Foil fencing tends to be very fast and uses a system of priority rules to determine who is awarded a point if both fencers land a hit. Valid points are only given for a hit on the torso. Hits elsewhere are "off-target".

In the event of an off-target hit, the bout is halted and the fencers moved apart before beginning again, but no point is scored. This is because in Smallsword fights, people would often be stabbed repeatedly rather than disabled by a single blow. A Smallsword wound might well not "stop" an assailant, though he would often bleed to death later or die from infection. Hits are only counted if made with the point; flat hits would not injure an opponent in a real duel, though done hard enough they can cause a good deal of irritation!

Self Defence Photos

Left: An image borrowed from Fencingsucks.com, demonstrating a frighteningly deep lunge.

Fencingsucks.com has a large collection of fencing images and generally pokes fun at our sport.

The other two weapons (Epee and Sabre) are sometimes referred to as "Advanced" weapons. This is not accurate, since although most beginners start with the Foil, it is possible to take up fencing from scratch with any of the weapons, and any or all of them can be taken to a high ("advanced") standard. Some fencers consider foil to be the 'hardest' weapon since the target area is small and attacks must be deep avoid falling short.

The Epee: The Epee is a direct descendent of the straight duelling sword. Similar to but heavier than the Foil, the Epee can only score with a thrust but a hit anywhere on the body (even the little toe!) is counted as a hit. This is because the Epee (or any other heavy thrusting sword) has some measure of "stopping power" - a live blade would be capable of inflicting considerable tissue damage, breaking bones rather than skidding off them, and generally spoiling your whole day.

Self Defence Photos

Left: Another fencingsucks.com image, this time from the 1996 Atlanta Olympics. The fencer at right is launching a fleche (running) attack. The guy at left looks like he’s intending something similar but has been beaten to it.

Rushing in like this is a bit all-or-nothing. Either you score or you get hit. Well-timed it’s devastating. Bad timing turns it into a sort of assisted suicide.

There is no priority system in Epee: the first hit that lands is counted, and double-hits are possible. Epee is about as close to real duelling as you can get. Fights are often technical and subtle, since the heavy weapon does not forgive mistakes that place you out of position. Epees are stiff. Where a Foil flexes readily upon a hard hit, with an Epee it is generally the target that does any bending. Epee is thus the most hazardous of the fencing weapons, though all of them are carefully designed to be very safe. Three people died in fencing accidents during the 20th Century, all of them at the Epee. On balance, that's a pretty good safety record.

The Sabre: The sabre is a light cut-and thrust weapon based on the cavalry sword. Sabre bouts tend to be fast and mobile, with fencers keeping their distance between attacks since with a cutting weapon it is quite possible to be hit by accident. Hits are scored with point or edge, anywhere above the waist. Below the waist is "off-target" in the same manner as Foil. (Slicing a horseman across the leg may upset him somewhat, but it is unlikely to disable him immediately and his counterstroke is often fatal; the Sabre rules attempt to reflect this.) Sabre parries tend to be stronger, almost "blocks", rather than the subtle deflections common with the other two weapons. Priority rules are used, similarly to the Foil.

Right: Another fleche attack, this time at sabre. The fleche is no longer allowed in sabre competition, which is a bit of a shame.

Sabre fencing tends to be very fast and mobile, with fencers staying out of reach until they intend to attack then closing in fast to make their hit.

Fencing Photos

Being clouted over the head with a sabre is quite an experience! The fencing mask is pretty resilient, so you can hit the head harder than unarmoured bits of the body. This leads to a common sabreur's apology - "sorry about that, I was aiming at your head!" – which is actually quite sincere. A blow that would cause nothing more serious than some ringing in the ears and a wry grin from the recipient can be quite painful if it hits the sword arm or shoulder instead of the armoured head.

Electric Judging Equipment:
Since running a competition using live blades is probably not a good idea, fencing matches use electric apparatus to determine if a hit has been made. The blades move very fast; it is often difficult to tell whether an attack landed, or where exactly, even for an experienced referee (or President, to use the former term, which I personally think is much nicer.) The electric apparatus is, on balance, a good thing.

But…

Sadly, the limitations of early electric equipment led to the creation of a number of tricks, whereby the fencer tries to complete the circuit and get the hit light on rather than land a classical sword thrust. I don't mean cheating with micro switches, but tricks like the flick-hit, whereby the point is whipped around a parry or even over the opponent's back. So long as the tip of the weapon is depressed on contact or the circuit is made, the light comes on and a hit is given.

I personally have issues with this kind of thing, which seems to be nothing more than institutionalised gamesmanship. Flick-hitting arose from the limitations of the judging apparatus. It could now be eliminated by building a brief delay into the judging equipment such that the point had to hit and stay on the target for a short period rather than bouncing off immediately as it does on a flick. The only reason this has not been done is that flicking has become institutionalised as part of the "sport of fencing", which is no longer a "martial art" nor an attempt to simulate a real sword fight; fencing has wandered away down a road also taken by Tae Kwon Do, Judo, Wrestling, Boxing and other "Combat Sports" – in evolving and gaining popularity as a sporting activity it has moved away from its origins by a series of almost imperceptible steps. A return, even part-way, is not desirable to many fencers.

My own opinions on the subject have resulted in being labelled as some sort of Luddite, a caveman or a "duellist". Well, such is the price of having opinions. I do believe that fencing is a fabulous sport; it's good enough to have taken over 15 years of my life. But there are ways it could be better. Your opinion may well differ!

Having said all that; modifications have recently been made to the electric judging apparatus which, along with other moves in the fencing world, have downgraded the flick considerably. Some people still do it but for the most part we’re returned to stabbing one another as gentlemen ought to do.


FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

So what’s this about then?

Fencing has its origins in the European sword martial arts, but today it’s a sport rather than a fighting system. There are three disciplines; the foil, the epee and the sabre. Each is slightly different, and for that reason we start everyone off with the foil and then let them try the others if they wish.

The aim of the game is to hit (or more accurately ‘touch’ – there is no need to batter one another senseless) the opponent with the point or edge of the weapon. The valid target area differs between the weapons. Defence is accomplished by parrying or evading the attack. At a set number of points (five is common), one of the fencers has won the bout. Simple in theory, though in practice it can get a bit more complex. That’s kind of the point…

I’ve never done this before

We all started that way. Most of our intake is complete beginners, so it’s not a problem. We teach everything you need to become an accomplished fencer.

Looks difficult. I’m not sure I could learn to do that…

There is a bit of a learning curve, yes. But we have a policy of getting people to the point where they can fence ‘a bit’ in their first session; enough to try the sport. After that, there’s plenty to learn but there’s no long period of training before you get to fence.

I missed the beginner’s course

Wander in any time. We’ll assign someone to bring you up to speed.

Do I need to be fit?

Not really. It helps if you intend to compete, but it’s possible to fence at quite a high level without being an athlete. Obviously, as with any sport your coordination, agility and cardio-vascular fitness will improve anyway.

What about health issues?

Fencing is one of the most open sports available. There are blind (yes, really) and wheelchair fencing events as well as more mainstream sporting contests. If you can physically get into the gym, we can teach you to fence. Please feel free to discuss any concerns with the coaches.

Is it dangerous? Does it hurt?

In order: No, and no. The weapons are not sharp and the safety equipment is extremely good. Since 1987 we have recorded one accident (a bruised finger!). Fencers are trained to fight safely, if that’s not a contradiction in terms, and to avoid being heavy-handed. Anyone who is not meeting the required safety standard is corrected or not allowed to fence until the problem is sorted out.

What about Competition?

It’s there if you want it. We’re in BUSA of course and there are various local and national events including special novice competitions and friendly matches against local clubs. You don’t have to be any good to compete – everyone who wants to enter competition can do so, and some of our total beginners have surprised their opponents from time to time. However, nobody is forced to compete if they don’t want to.

Typical Session?

We’d normally start with a functional warm-up (which means some footwork drills and the like, warming up by practicing necessary fencing skills) followed by a class lesson. That means learning and practicing the strokes used with the various weapons plus sessions on tactics, competition technique and, well, how to win a fencing match. After that we open the floor for ‘freeplay’, ie fencing different opponents to try out your skills. Some sessions we might run a mini-competition or do something more unusual.

Are there belts and grades?

Not really. Individuals progress at different rates and tend to measure their prowess by who they recently beat or how they do in competition. It’s very much an individual thing. At some point you will cease to be a beginner. Later you’ll beat an opponent you couldn’t before. These achievements are very much personal ones even if you’re part of a team.